Are we critical? Are they lazy?
It's not uncommon for us to pass around web designer / studio web sites at PRPL. Someone tweets out a blog post, sends in a job application, we see something on a CSS gallery--however these sites reach our computers the result can typically end the same way: we start playing [for a lack of a better on-the-spot name] the 10-second game.
What's the 10-second game? Someone finds a continuity error on the page and we challenge each other to find the design flaw, programming error or UI anti-pattern in 10 seconds or less upon page load. What happens if we find it? We laugh, high-five, and the process usually will snowball into tearing apart a website. What happens if we don't find it? We train ourselves to look for these things in the future.
This competition doesn't always go forward, however, there are sites out there that blow us away. Inevitably for me personally, they get bookmarked and become a role model; a standard rule for how a project should be considered "done". It simply blows my mind that companies, designers and even programmers can write off aesthetic problems as acceptable or, perhaps worse, not even notice them.
Sure, this is partially a rant of, "Don't call yourself a designer if you don't take pride in your work," but also an introspection of myself. Are we too critical of our peers, or are they simply lazy or uncaring? Perhaps it's a difference in company culture, or a rushed job that reflects poorly across the entire brand? There are excuses miles deep for any small issue, but it's like sand in my eyes--I just can't see past the problems and it discredits my entire experience.
The take away? I'm not going to explicitly name one, just voicing my thoughts.








Comments
Michael Parler (not verified) says:
Published on Nov 6, 2009 @ 11:38am
Maybe we can co-write a book on the Do's and Don'ts of applying in today's technology industry.
Then by time its published, the book will be obsolete and we can hand-carve boats for a living.
Rob Zienert (not verified) says:
Published on Nov 6, 2009 @ 12:27pm
Please. The future is in DocBook, we don't need to wait until it's finished to publish it. :P
I do like where you're going on this whole hand-carved aqua-vessels thing, though. It's a better alternative to the lumberjack future we've been talking about.
Daniel J. Sieradski (not verified) says:
Published on Nov 6, 2009 @ 12:28pm
Here's my submission for the 10 second test on this very page:
http://screencast.com/t/ppOWM7eAmV
Check out the placement of the user icon next to Parler's comment.
;)
Rob Zienert (not verified) says:
Published on Nov 6, 2009 @ 12:30pm
I was actually going to make mention on that as it's something we have in our ticketing system. Of course, we aren't perfect by any stretch of the imagination. Won't prevent me from whipping the front-end guys, though. ;)
Terry Howard (not verified) says:
Published on Feb 3, 2010 @ 14:13pm
Yeah, I can't hardly look at a website without viewing source, much in the same way I have a friend in pre-press who starts examining any printed piece put before him for registration, line screens, etc... Anyone who truly cares about their craft will do that.
Incidentally: http://www.google.com/search?q=purple+rock+scissors
Check the Google Site Links, it looks like some old pages of yours (http://purplerockscissors.com/company/who-we-are/) are redirecting to a domain name you no longer own (prpl.com) and many of your links go to a domain squatter shilling pills.
It happens to the best of us!
Rob Zienert (not verified) says:
Published on Feb 15, 2010 @ 18:04pm
Terry, How true you are. Drupal has a tendency to produce some pretty gnarly markup -- it's something that we're in a constant battle with. For this reason among many others, I'm not a personal fan of auto-magic. As for the broken links, we're constantly evolving here at PRPL and along with that comes our website. This installation specifically, was done primarily as an experiment to see how much we could get done on a website from conceptualization to live production in a single work week. Thanks for informing us of these issues, they're certainly things that we've been trying to remedy.
Post new comment